Podcast: When Should Journalists Allow Sources to Remain Anonymous?

By

July 20, 2022

Categories

Media, Podcasts

Tags

, ,

Share

We often hear of anonymous sources in the context of an undercover source with dirt. Deeply entrenched, or in the case of the 1976 movie, “All the President’s Men,” deep-throated…

[MOVIE CLIP]  Deep Throat: “The list is longer than anyone can imagine. It involved the entire U.S. intelligence community.  FBI, CIA, Justice…it’s incredible. The coverup had little to do with Watergate.  It was mainly to protect the covert operations…”

More recently, confidential sources were often referenced during the Trump Administration, leaking behind-the-scenes accounts that infuriated the president and his inner circle.

[TRUMP RALLY CLIP] President Trump: “The media is the enemy. They take the word ‘fake’ out.  And now I’m saying, “Oh no, this is no good.’ But that’s the way they are.  They shouldn’t be allowed to use sources unless they use somebody’s name.  Let their name be put out there.  Let their name be put out.”

Journalists debate the worth of keeping a source anonymous, which can yield important secrets or let someone fire off claims without accountability. But outside the political circles of power, when is it allowable to give everyday people a cloak of secrecy?  And in what way?

This is NYU’s Law & Ethics podcast for the week of July 12, 2022.   In this episode, I’ll share two examples of when I gave sources confidentiality to get important insights. The music is by Karl Casey of White Bat Audio.

 

Related Posts

November 16, 2022

Podcast: Troubling Trends in True Crime

The "true crime" genre continues to trend upwards in terms of production, consumption, and financial gain. But for journalists, is engaging with this genre ethical?

July 27, 2022

Podcast: Should Media Censor Dead Bodies On Television for Children?

Children in America today learn about lockdowns, not talking to strangers, and the meaning of death. But with school shootings on the rise, should dead children on television be part of that education?