Washington State’s Ban on For-Profit Prisons in Danger as California’s Circuit Court Finds Similar Case Unconstitutional


November 15, 2022


Law & Justice


, , , , ,


(TACOMA, Wash.) — The GEO Group, one of the world’s largest for-profit prison companies,  is seeking to block a private prison ban in Washington state. A recent ruling in California could lend precedent in their favor. 

In April 2021, GEO Group asked the U.S District Court in Tacoma for an injunction against the passing of a bill that prevents for-profit detention facilities from operating in Washington. The bill  would also shut down any current operations by 2025. 

As a private federal contractor, GEO Group operates Washington’s only U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention center.

According to initial complaint documents, the company asked the court to declare the bill unconstitutional. Citing the United States’ “Supremacy Clause”, which places superiority of federal operations over state law, the company argued that shutting down the ICE facility stands in direct conflict with federal immigration operations.  

In a counterclaim, Washington’s Governor Jay Inslee and State Attorney General Bob Ferguson asked the current ban to be upheld and demanded that GEO immediately cease operations of their Tacoma facility.

In October 2021, the district court put a stay on all proceedings until a ruling was made on a similar court case in California. 

In that case, GEO Group and the U.S. Department of Justice (USDOJ) asked for a stop to California’s ban on for-profit prisons and detention centers. They were originally denied an injunction in district court but appealed that decision to the Ninth Circuit Court.

The Ninth Circuit Court ruled in favor of GEO Group and the USDOJ,  but only in the case of privately owned immigration detention centers by ICE. In a final opinion statement, the court noted that the California bill was unconstitutional and “impeding on federal immigration policy.”

The California decision could have real consequences for Washington by providing a precedent for overturning the state’s private prison ban. 

The Click reached out to those involved in the Washington case and have not received a reply.

Related Posts

Host of Climate Town filming episode in NYC

July 11, 2023

Opinion: A Potent Cocktail for Change: Mixing Advocacy Journalism With Comedy

Comedian Rollie Williams uses his YouTube channel to make climate change funny and actionable. He's got a degree in climate science, so you know he's straight up legit.

Book cover of "I'm a Brilliant Little Black Boy!" (horizontal, purple background, showcasing a smiling boy on the side with different artifacts on the ground) and "I Am Every Good Thing" (vertical, red background, only showcasing a boy with his arms crossed across the cover).

May 12, 2023

Similar Books About Plucky Black Boys Spark Copyright Suit Against Penguin Random House

The co-author of "I’m a Brilliant Little Black Boy!" is suing the publisher over "striking similarities" with a book it published.

Verified by MonsterInsights